By Sara Bill
Victim Assistance Coordinator in the 24th Judicial District Attorney’s Office
Victim assistance coordinators (VACs) are the bridge between crime victims and the criminal justice system. While victims’ rights are guaranteed under Chapter 56A, those rights have little practical value unless victims receive timely information, meaningful assistance, and compassionate guidance throughout the prosecution process. The responsibility of making those rights a reality often rests with the VAC.
For me, the key to meeting the notification requirements is having consistent procedures and making communication with the victim a priority from the very beginning of the case.
Start with a phone call
The first step I take is to make an initial telephone call to the victim as soon as possible after our office receives the case. While it is not required by Chapter 56A, I have found it to be one of the most valuable steps in establishing a relationship with the victim and creating a reliable system for future communication.
I make the initial call using the office’s main telephone number so our office name appears on the caller ID. This helps victims recognize that the call is legitimate. It also provides an important practical benefit: If the victim misses my call and returns it, there will be someone at the office to answer the call or take a message.
That first conversation gives me an opportunity to introduce myself, explain my role, and let victims know that they have someone in our office they can contact with any questions about the case. I also use this initial contact to gather and verify all the information I will need for future notifications. I obtain the victim’s mailing address, telephone number, email address, and any other appropriate contact information. I also ask for an alternate telephone number (for instance, from a best friend or trusted family member) and, when appropriate, obtain permission to use that number if I am ever unable to reach her and need assistance locating her.
I have found that this information is much easier to obtain early in the process. The victim is often more engaged immediately after the offense and more willing to communicate with our office. As a case progresses and prosecution takes longer than the victim anticipated, circumstances can change. Victims may become frustrated, they may relocate, they might change telephone numbers, or they can become less willing to cooperate for a variety of reasons.
This is also an opportunity to explain what victims can expect from our office. I explain that they will receive various forms, letters, and notifications as the case progresses, and I ask how they prefer to receive those communications. Once the victim identifies their preferred method of communication, I document that preference in our case file and use it for future notifications. Whether the victim prefers regular mail, email, text messages, telephone calls, or another method, documenting that preference ensures that everyone handling the case is aware of how the victim has asked to be contacted. I also update the case file whenever contact information changes.
The Victim Information Packet
Once an indictment or information has been filed, the required Victim Information Packet and other applicable documentation are sent to the victim using the victim’s preferred method of communication—regular mail or email—depending on the circumstances and the information they have provided. Because I have usually spoken with victims beforehand, this is not necessarily their first contact with our office. They have already met me, at least by telephone, and have an understanding of my role and what to expect.
I do not send Victim Information Packets by certified mail. In my experience, victims will sometimes refuse to accept or sign for a certified letter because they are concerned it is a legal document or that signing for it may somehow obligate them to do something. A certified envelope can immediately create anxiety for someone who may already be unfamiliar with the criminal justice system. I try to make mailed letters appear less legalistic and formal whenever possible, as I believe a more approachable presentation helps avoid intimidating the recipient and encourages them to read and respond to the correspondence.
Using regular mail makes the required documentation less intimidating. Instead of receiving an unexpected packet of legal information from an unfamiliar office, victims know who sent it, why they are receiving it, and who they can contact if they have questions.
My goal is for the communication to go directly to the victim without creating unnecessary apprehension. It is a required communication, but I want it to feel as much like a communication from someone who is there to help, not something that causes the victim to hesitate before opening the envelope.
There is also a practical benefit to this approach. If the letter is returned as undeliverable, I know fairly quickly that I need to contact the victim and obtain an updated address. I can then resend the information to the correct address. This practice helps keep mailing costs down while also giving me a quicker indication that a victim may have moved. I don’t personally use the U.S. Postal Service’s “return service requested” option; it is a benefit from the post office. Rather than forwarding the letter, the post office will return an undeliverable letter back to the sender (with a yellow sticker with the receiver’s new address on it). Other VACs do use this service and find it helpful for knowing that a victim’s address has changed.
Keeping victims informed after the initial setting
Once a case moves beyond the initial setting, keeping up with resets becomes an important part of my routine.
After each docket, letters advising victims of the new setting dates are sent to those who are entitled to notification and to those who have requested it. These notifications are also sent using the method the victim has selected, whether regular mail or email.
There are also circumstances in which traditional mail and email may not be an option. For victims who may be homeless or displaced, those who have safety concerns, or victims who are otherwise difficult to reach, text messaging may be an appropriate means of maintaining communication. When the victim has provided a number and consented to that method of contact, I use the office-issued cell phone rather than my personal phone. This keeps the communication within the office’s established business communication system.
The goal is consistency. Victims should not have to wonder whether they will be told when something happens in their case.
Communicating plea offers
Our office customarily recommends a plea offer before the pre-trial setting. Once prosecutors have determined what they believe is an appropriate offer, I contact the victim by telephone and convey the offer. This conversation serves two purposes. First, it allows victims to understand what is being proposed and to ask questions so they have a clear understanding of the offer and the potential resolution of the case. Second, it gives victims an opportunity to share their thoughts, concerns, and views regarding the offer. I then communicate the victim’s feedback to the prosecutor for consideration.
When communicating plea offers to a victim, I explain that the offer represents a good-faith effort to resolve the matter without proceeding to a jury trial. I emphasize that this is a proposed offer and that the defendant may accept the plea. If the defendant rejects the offer, the matter may still proceed to a jury trial. Additionally, I discuss the written Victim Impact Statement and the right of allocution. It helps victims begin to mentally prepare what they want to say.
The victim’s input is important, but the ultimate decision regarding the prosecution and disposition of the criminal case rests with prosecutors. At times, prosecutors may determine that the offer can be amended to address the victim’s wishes or concerns. If the victim is not in agreement with the plea offer, the prosecutor will advise the court accordingly at the time of the plea.
Throughout this process, I document my conversations with victims in our case management software. Good documentation is essential. It creates a record of the communication, the information provided, the victim’s response, and any follow-up that may be necessary.
Preparing the victim for the plea
Once a plea agreement has been reached, I make sure victims receive sufficient notice of the plea hearing so they can attend and so they may provide an oral statement if they choose.
Again, this goes back to the importance of the initial conversation. Because the victim has already been told how our office communicates with them and what types of notifications they can expect, the process is more predictable. For many victims, knowing what is going to happen and knowing whom they can call with questions can make an unfamiliar court process easier to navigate.
Case dispositions
Victim notification does not end when the defendant enters a plea or the court disposes of the case. After disposition, I send victims a letter advising them of the details of the disposition. This provides the victim with a written record of what occurred and allows me to close the communication loop with them. If the case is resolved by plea, the defendant waives the right to appeal, and typically no appeal will be filed.
Following a jury conviction, I meet with victims to discuss the outcome and explain the next steps in the process. During that meeting, I advise victims that an appeal will likely be filed, and if so, I will continue to provide case-related information and updates, consistent with the communication and support provided throughout the original criminal proceedings.
The deadline for filing a notice of appeal is generally 30 days after the conviction. Because VACs may not consistently receive notices or updates regarding appellate proceedings, I set reminders to periodically review the local court’s file for any filings or related activity. This helps ensure that any necessary follow-up with the victim is addressed in a timely manner.
If one is filed, I will provide written communication about the appeal and relevant case information from the applicable court of appeals. This information includes instructions for following the status online at www.txcourts .gov/cca. Providing victims with a direct link to access their case information allows them to monitor the proceedings and stay informed if they choose to.
When a defendant is sentenced to prison and after he is transferred, I send a final letter providing the victim with the name and address of the correctional facility, the defendant’s TDCJ (Texas Department of Criminal Justice) number, and the parole eligibility date. This information is obtained from https://inmate.tdcj.texas.gov/ InmateSearch.
The prison letter also provides information regarding how the victim can stay informed of the offender’s status through the Integrated Victim Services System (IVSS). The IVSS system provides information about an offender’s custodial status while in TDCJ. It does not provide any information about the status of an appeal.
I maintain contact with victims as long as there is activity or information to convey. This is particularly important because the conclusion of the court case does not necessarily mean the end of victims’ involvement with the criminal justice system. Parole notifications and other post-conviction information may become important in the future. Like all other communications, information about the parole and appeals processes are provided orally and written.
Develop a system that works for your office
The trick to successfully meeting the requirements of Chapter 56A is to establish procedures that make the process consistent and manageable. Every office will have different resources, staffing levels, case-manage- ment systems, and practices. The important thing is to develop a system that works for your office and then follow it consistently.
For me, that system begins with the first telephone call and continues through disposition. I verify contact information early. I establish the victim’s preferred method of communication. I explain what they can expect. I document my conversations. I send notifications consistently as the case progresses. I communicate plea offers and obtain the victim’s thoughts for the prosecutor. And finally, I make sure the victim receives information regarding the final disposition and, when applicable, post-conviction information.
None of these steps is complicated by itself. The challenge is making sure they happen consistently, even as caseloads increase and cases become more complicated.
Conclusion
Most importantly, I try to remember that what may be a routine notification to us can be extremely important to the person receiving it. A reset letter may be the difference between a victim knowing what happened with the case and believing the case has been forgotten. A telephone call about a plea offer may give a victim an opportunity to have her voice heard. A final disposition letter may provide the closure he has been waiting for.
Chapter 56A gives victims important rights. Our job as VACs is to make sure those rights are meaningful in practice. Meet the statutory requirements, but never lose sight of the person behind the case number.