By Sarah Stallberg
Assistant County Attorney in Montgomery County
A woman was finishing her morning run on the sidewalk in her own neighborhood when she saw a man with a small black Belgian Malinois on a leash; he and the dog were walking in her direction on the sidewalk. The dog didn’t look threatening. But as she passed by, the dog lunged at her and attacked. The woman fell to the ground and tried to defend herself while the owner tried to gain control of the dog. She tried crawling into the nearby woods, but the dog repeatedly attacked her. Her injuries were serious, and emergency services was called to apply a tourniquet to her arm to control the severe bleeding. That tourniquet turned out to be life-saving medical care.
The victim started her long road to recovery, but what will happen to the dog? Criminal prosecutors are often familiar with dog attacks, but on the civil side, animal control or law enforcement might have questions about the more immediate possibility for civil remedies in response to a dog attack that caused injuries. Many questions might flood your mind during that initial call (What happened? How is the victim? Is anyone else in immediate danger? What can you do today to protect the community? How long will we quarantine or house the dog?), but what exactly are some of your legal options as a civil prosecutor? And which option should you choose?
First things first: dog bites
Dog bites happen at all hours of the day and night, and the scenes are as wild as your imagination. The Texas Health and Safety Code authorizes both animal control officers and law enforcement to investigate, handle, and potentially seize an animal in cases involving animal cruelty, dangerous dogs, and serious bodily injuries following dog attacks.[1]
On the initial call, ask officers and animal control for photographs of bite wounds, witness statements, the victim’s statement, video footage if available, and medical records of the victim and dog(s) involved.[2] In this case, not only did we have an organized and cooperative victim along with her written statement, but we also had written statements from two Good Samaritans who called 911 and stopped to help when they were driving by during the attack. Those statements and the brave witnesses—one who intervened with her car (pulling off the road and honking her horn at the dog for distraction) and others who physically helped the victim—painted the picture of what happened from outside the victim’s perspective as she was fighting for her life.
Dog bites that break the skin require the dog to be quarantined either at home or at a veterinary clinic (at the owner’s cost) until it can be determined that the dog does not have rabies.[3] Generally, the quarantine requirement will also protect the public during the investigation process, but when owners are unwilling or unable to sufficiently quarantine the dog and refuse to utilize the animal shelter quarantine process, there can be valid threats to public safety. In those cases, don’t be afraid to gather evidence, make necessary decisions, and take immediate action the same day.
Once the evidence has been gathered, the officer should create a bite incident report and/or activity report for your review of the facts. If there is no time to generate an official report due to the community safety threat, you can work off of witness statements, photographs, and/or videos to move forward quickly.
Is this a dangerous dog or a serious bodily injury (SBI) case?
When a dog bite breaks the victim’s skin, there are three basic options for the officer:
1) document the injury with no corresponding legal action;
2) determine that the dog is a dangerous dog and start the notification process, which has potentially serious legal implications for the dog; or
3) determine that the dog bite caused SBI to the victim and begin the legal process to advocate for humane euthanasia to protect the community.
Once you have reviewed the evidence, determine whether the wounds constitute serious bodily injury. SBI in a civil dog case is defined as “an injury characterized by severe bite wounds or severe ripping and tearing of muscle that would cause a reasonably prudent person to seek medical treatment from a medical professional and would require hospitalization without regard to whether the person actually sought medical treatment.”[4] In our case, it qualified as SBI because of the large, deep, open wound. Generally, you can tell a wound will qualify as SBI when you glance at a picture. However, we have also filed SBI cases that meet the definition and the victim is young and/or the wound is in a delicate location. For example, if it meets the definition of severe and it’s on a child’s face, you can see muscle, or it required stitches, it’s probably worth taking to the judge. Of course, if the dog caused an individual’s death, it will automatically qualify as an SBI case.[5]
Note that a case can be considered SBI even if the victim did not actually receive professional medical treatment (and if you don’t know what ripped or torn muscle looks like, you can always ask your favorite internet search engine for images). This civil definition, and a preponderance of the evidence standard, looks very different from the evidence necessary in a criminal case, which requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt that the victim sustained “bodily injury that creates a substantial risk of death or that causes death, serious permanent disfigurement, or protracted loss or impairment of the function of any bodily member or organ.”[6]
So it’s serious bodily injury—now what?
If you believe the wound meets the definition of SBI, a sworn complaint can be filed by “any person” including the county attorney or a peace officer.[7] The application for a warrant to seize the animal, along with paperwork setting a hearing date, must be submitted to a judge. These warrants are usually filed in the justice court but could also be filed in county court.[8] The application must contain a sworn complaint that the dog being seized has caused the death of or serious bodily injury to a person by attacking, biting, or mauling, and that sworn complaint must contain sufficient probable cause to believe that the dog caused the death of or serious bodily injury to the person stated in the complaint.[9] As a practical matter, the victim should complete a written statement. However, if the victim is too injured, you can also use medical information or records and other evidence to support the case. We have also used statements physically written by the victim’s designee and signed by the victim. Statements can be typed or handwritten of course, but there will always be something about unique handwriting that seems more personal (if you can read it). In this case, our victim was able to write her own statement with help from a family member after returning from the hospital.
Prior to submission of the warrant application to the court, review the paperwork to advise whether more details are needed from witnesses or medical professionals or whether you should offer more evidence, such as pictures, to better establish that probable cause exists. (Don’t forget that a picture is worth a thousand words!) The pictures of the Malinois attack were gruesome and included before and after photos, along with a few showing the scene for context. There was no doubt in anyone’s mind that this was a SBI case after seeing the pictures. But don’t forget when drafting the warrant that sometimes extra caution is necessary not to reveal the identity of the reporting individual when the identity is unknown to the dog’s owner.[10] This can be especially true when the reporter was a neighbor or someone who specifically requested not to be involved.
If the court agrees with your SBI analysis, it is likely that humane euthanasia will be the outcome because of the severity of the attack and possible reoccurrence with release. Section 822.003 of the Texas Health and Safety Code provides that the court shall order humane euthanasia if the dog is responsible for a person’s death. However, if death is not involved, the court will have discretion to either order humane euthanasia or release the dog.[11]
There can also be times, depending on the facts of the case, where showing some human compassion for the dog’s owner can go a long way toward achieving an appropriate resolution. While court is one option, the owner could also choose to voluntarily surrender the dog to animal control and authorize humane euthanasia (where the owner will not be part of the process at the very end). In appropriate cases, the owner may be offered an option to choose humane euthanasia at his own cost from any chosen veterinarian so the owner can stay with the animal during the process. In those situations, the officer follows up with the veterinarian to obtain documentation to close out the file. That process by agreement is both effective and efficient while protecting the community, which is always the overarching goal.
If the owner is not in agreement with humane euthanasia, as in our example case, you can follow the process through court proceedings. After the application for a warrant has been filed and you obtained the signed warrant from the court to seize the dog, the dog must be impounded in a secure and humane condition (usually at the local animal shelter) until the hearing.[12] When the warrant is signed, the court will also issue written notice of a hearing that must be held within 10 days.[13] The notice of hearing must be given to the owner and person who made the complaint.[14] I would recommend having law enforcement personally serve these notices and warrants, along with filing the returns with the court, so that the sufficiency of the hearing notice is not a future issue.
Preparing for the SBI hearing
Once the court has set the hearing date, determine who would be the best witnesses for the hearing. Dog hearings are often difficult because people are understandably emotionally invested, and the victim has suffered trauma. Dog owners often feel like the life of their “child” is at stake. And while you may identify with some of the emotions involved, it is important to maintain sight of the responsibility to advocate for community safety and recognize that ultimately, the decision will be at the judge’s discretion.
In this case, the victim testified about the multiple attacks by the dog, including all of the details for the judge to understand what was happening immediately prior to the attacks, during them, and the dog’s aggressive demeanor when it was removed from the scene by the owner. She also talked about her ongoing and anticipated future medical needs as well as the way these injuries have and likely will continue to affect her life. The paramedic also testified about the victim’s injuries and scene of the attack. Because these hearings are held within 10 days of the filing, victims are often in court with fresh bandages and wounds that the judge can see.[15]
Do not underestimate the importance of preparing witnesses prior to the hearing so that you know what they might say. Don’t assume that SBI victims, even in horrific cases, always want to see the dog euthanized. Our standard practice is to allow the victim to testify and give her a voice in the process if she chooses to do so, along with the officer who handled the dog during the seizure process. The testimony of these two witnesses often provides enough evidence to show that the dog caused serious bodily injury. However, to tell the full story, we also provide the court with photographs of the victim’s wounds and other relevant information. If the victim does not want to be involved, we use the officer with the most personal knowledge. The officer establishes the case using facts gathered and observations made during the investigation, photographs, and business records from the file. Plan ahead to strike the balance between not enough and too much, as you want to avoid repetitive emotional testimony and minimize new trauma for the victim.
Sometimes we offer additional testimony on how the dog’s behavior has been since the seizure, such as if it has maintained its aggression or also bit a shelter employee, so that the judge has the full picture of the situation. Often, the owner will offer evidence and pictures showing how great the dog is, how much it is loved by its vet or groomer, how it fits in the family, that it had prior training, or the owner’s plans for future obedience training. And while I’m sure all of that is true, none of it diminishes the victim’s serious injuries or provides any guarantee of safety to the community that we are charged with protecting. At the end of the day, the goal is to provide the judge with sufficient information so that an educated decision can be rendered based on the evidence.
Remember that this is a civil not a criminal case, so the Fifth Amendment will not prohibit prosecutors from calling the owner as a witness and requiring him to answer questions about the dog. The owner and his girlfriend also testified, which did not help their case.
Judicial options
Any situation other than a victim’s death involves judicial discretion on whether the dog should be released to its owner or humanely euthanized.[16] Other choices include ordering the dog released to the person from whom the dog was seized or any other person authorized to take possession of the dog.[17]
It is important to note that there are defenses provided in §822.003(f) of the Texas Health & Safety Code. These relate to where the attack occurred, whether the victim was trespassing, or if the dog was being used to defend a person from assault or theft when it bit the victim. If the court finds that either serious bodily injury did not occur or that one of the defenses applies, the court must release the dog. However, judicial denial of a SBI finding is not the end of your choices. The court can order that the dog is declared a “dangerous dog” if you included that alternative option in your pleadings, or if you didn’t, the “animal control authority” can follow the administrative route.[18]
Dangerous dogs
A dangerous dog is statutorily defined as “a dog that (A) makes an unprovoked attack on a person that causes bodily injury and occurs in a place other than an enclosure in which the dog was being kept and that was reasonably certain to prevent the dog from leaving the enclosure on its own; or (B) commits unprovoked acts in a place other than an enclosure in which the dog was being kept and that was reasonably certain to prevent the dog from leaving the enclosure on its own and those acts cause a person to reasonably believe that the dog will attack and cause bodily injury to that person.”[19]
Generally, dangerous dogs are subject to that legal finding as the result of an administrative finding.[20] Dogs that are administratively determined to be dangerous are subject to requirements including:
1) registration;
2) restraint at all times on a leash in the immediate control of a person or in a secure enclosure;
3) $100,000 insurance policy or proof of financial responsibility to cover liability for an attack; and
4) compliance with other municipal or county regulations and requirements.
“Secure enclosure” is a statutory term that requires the fenced area or structure to be locked, capable of preventing entry and escape, clearly marked as containing a dangerous dog, and in compliance with any other local regulations.[21] For example, in addition to statutory requirements, the Montgomery County animal regulations for dangerous dogs also mandate: 1) locked enclosures 6 feet high and at least nine-gauge wire if applicable; 2) sterilization of the dog; 3) a microchip implant; and 4) an insurance verification affidavit.[22]
Dangerous dog cases can be the result of administrative or judicial findings as the result of dog bites that were less than SBI, or dogs that commit an aggressive act that made a reasonable person believe they were in imminent danger of being physically attacked. The statutory definition generally excludes dogs that were in reasonable enclosures, such as their well-fenced backyard, unless the victim was invited into that backyard so the dog was not in a separate, secure enclosure. For example, a dangerous dog finding could be appropriate where dogs are running loose away from their property and that lunged at or aggressively ran while barking toward neighbors who were checking the mailbox on their own property. A correct legal analysis would also differentiate between whether the dog running at the possible victim is a 10-pound Chihuahua named Betty or a 120-pound Rottweiler named Killer.
What if the owner does not comply?
Owners generally have 30 days to comply with dangerous dog requirements. If they are not fully compliant, the statute directs the owner to deliver the dog to the animal control authority.[23] If that does not occur, prosecutors can file an application for a hearing for the court to determine the owner’s compliance with the dangerous dog requirements.[24] If, after notice and hearing, the court confirms the failure to comply, a warrant will be issued for seizure of the dog. After the dog is seized (the timeline does not begin on the day of the hearing or order), the owner has 10 more days to comply with the requirements, or the dog will be humanely euthanized without further court action or notice.[25]
Can these cases be appealed?
Dangerous dog appeals may continue through the court of appeals.[26] However, when you read the plain and unambiguous language of §822.003 of the Texas Health & Safety Code, it appears silent as to whether SBI cases can be appealed from justice court. Nonetheless, there is some caselaw supporting the opinion that there is still a right to appeal the SBI decision. For example, the Twelfth Court of Appeals noted that “statutes are to be construed in favor of the right to appeal.”[27] The Fifth Court of Appeals concluded that “Subchapter A of Chapter 822 of the Texas Health & Safety Code is subsumed by Subchapter D, and therefore, the right to appeal provided for in Subchapter D applies to appeals of proceedings provided in Subchapter A.”[28] Therefore, as a condition of perfecting an appeal, you should ask the justice court to set an appeal bond in the event the dog owner chooses to appeal the decision.
Procedurally, appeals should be made to a county court or a county court-at-law in the county in which the justice or municipal court is located.[29] Jury trials are also permitted. As a condition of perfecting the appeal, the appellant must file a notice of appeal not later than the 10th day after the date the decision by the justice court is issued, and if applicable, pay the appeal bond determined by the justice court.[30] Upon the perfection of an appeal from justice court, the case must be tried de novo in the county court in which an appeal has been filed.[31] Therefore, the entire case must be presented to the county court as if there had been no previous trial in the justice court.
Court costs, appeal bonds, and other fees
The owner shall pay any cost or fee assessed by the county’s governing body related to the seizure, acceptance, impoundment, or destruction of the dog.[32] If appealed to county court, the justice court shall set a bond in an amount to cover the estimated costs of housing and caring for the impounded dog during the appeal process.[33] Some courts may order the appellate bond to cover the dog’s daily housing costs based on the average time for an appellate decision. In this case, the appeal bond from JP to county court was $510, but the county court ordered costs over $720 (offset by some of the JP bond) with an appellate bond of over $4,000 to cover daily shelter charges of $15 for nine months.
Online resources
If you have never handled a case like this before or are looking for resources, such as forms, to use as a starting point, the Texas Justice Court Training Center has an Administrative Proceedings Deskbook at www.tjctc.org/resources/deskbooks.html and some helpful charts at www.tjctc .org/resources/charts-and-checklists .html. The Texas Municipal Courts Education Center also has forms at www.tmcec.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/16-Animal-Hearings-2026.pdf. As always, use the pleading and documents that best fit the facts and law that apply to your case, and modify them when necessary.
Conclusion
In case you’re wondering what happened to our victim, she ensured the safety of her community by going through the process of two courts: appearance in justice court and then county court after the owner appealed. She listened to evidence, along with the judges, including her testimony, the owner’s testimony, pictures of her severe injuries, and testimony from a paramedic who provided care at the scene. Both judges ordered that the dog be humanely euthanized and assessed costs against the owner as well as required appellate bonds. The owner chose not to appeal further, and the shelter’s costs were covered by the justice court appeal bond and additional money paid by the dog’s owner. The victim also sued the owner in civil court, and it appears that the case settled after mediation.
Dog cases can be challenging because Texas law considers dogs to be property, but they involve real people and real emotion that sometimes involves gruesome evidence. They require work, communication, and coordination. But they are often necessary to achieve the future safety of your community, and that makes it all worth it.
[1] See Tex. Health & Safety Code §§821.022 (cruelly treated animal), 822.001 (serious bodily injury), 822.041 (dangerous dogs).
[2] You should specifically ask your investigator whether security camera footage of the incident exists.
[3] Tex. Health & Safety Code §§826.042 and 826.043. Sometimes the dog qualifies for home quarantine with proof of previous rabies vaccination if it was not running loose. An owner’s failure to comply with the quarantine rules is a Class C misdemeanor. Id. at §826.044(b).
[4] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.001(2).
[5] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.002(a).
[6] Tex. Penal Code §1.07(46).
[7] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.002(a)(1).
[8] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.002(a).
[9] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.002.
[10] On a side note, the identity of the reporter may also not be subject to release under the Public Information Act. See Tex. Gov’t Code § 552.101; Roviaro v. United States, 353 U.S. 53 (1957); Open Records Decision No. 515 (1988).
[11] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.003(e).
[12] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.002(b).
[13] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.003(a). It does need to be far out enough on the calendar to serve the owner and have the return filed with the Court – so more than a few days but not more than ten. For practical purposes, we generally do not oppose the owner’s Motion for Continuance when necessary based on good cause, such as hiring an attorney or unavailability, unless there are safety concerns otherwise. We do not file motions for continuance on behalf of the State in light of the statutory references.
[14] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.003(b).
[15] Because these cases are appealable, don’t forget to describe—for the record—with words what everyone in court can see with their eyes. Don’t let the record only describe the victim’s injuries as “fresh” or “right here.”
[16] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.003(e).
[17] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.003(e).
[18] “Animal control authority” varies in each county, and includes a county animal control office with authority over the area where the dog is kept or a county sheriff in an area with no animal control office. Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.041(1).
[19] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.041(2).
[20] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.041(1). Certain counties are subject to THSC §822.0422 rather than §822.0421.
[21] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.041(4).
[22] https://cms1files.revize.com/montgomerycountytx/ Animal%20Control%20Update.pdf?t=20250828144829626
[23] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.042(b). This may be unlikely to happen voluntarily.
[24] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.042(c).
[25] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.042(e).
[26] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.042(e-1).
[27] Hayes v. State, 518 S.W.3d 585, 590 (Tex. App.—Tyler 2017, no pet.).
[28] State By and Through City of Dallas v. Dallas Pets Alive, 566 S.W.3d 914, 918 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2018, pet. denied).
[29] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.0424 (a).
[30] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.0424(b).
[31] Tex. R. Civ. P. 506.3.
[32] Tex. Health & Safety Code §822.042(d).
[33] Tex. Health & Safety Code §§821.0423(c-1) and 822.0424(b).