Podcasts, Justice Matters, Outreach
November-December 2026

The Justice Matters podcast

By Aaron Setliff
Assistant County Attorney in El Paso County

In a 2025 issue of this journal, TDCAA Executive Director Shannon Edmonds wrote about something he called “The Rupture.” “That’s my nickname for that roughly six-month span from March to September 2020 when the world turned upside down,” he wrote. “The Rupture resulted in—or at a minimum, greatly contributed to—an erosion of cultural and political norms and an increase in the distrust of core institutions in our country.”[1]

                  In the following issue, he wrote, “The resulting challenges to recruitment, retention, and reputation are still felt today, yet many of you are taking steps to improve morale within your offices and bolster your communities’ external views of your offices.”[2] He included a blurb about something we are doing in El Paso: a podcast called Justice Matters. It started a couple of years ago as I was pondering a way to recast our community’s understanding of our two prosecutor offices and the work we do.

                  The last few years have certainly created difficult, new dynamics for prosecutors. In particular, in El Paso, we experienced the disruptions Shannon mentioned as well as a series of jolting leadership changes at our District Attorney’s Office. In the midst of societal turmoil, our DA resigned under pressure of removal, the governor then appointed a new DA, and after a few months our current DA, James Montoya, was elected into office. We also saw a transition in the office in which I work, the County Attorney’s Office. Although elected County Attorney Christina Sanchez handled the transition expertly, this was challenging in the sense that she took over from a long-serv- ing and well-respected predecessor during a time of continued local and national tumult.

                  Having done a little podcasting,[3] I had learned that this medium is a completely attainable, workable, and potentially effective way to share information. I’ve been a podcast listener since, well, The Rupture. I’d go on long runs along the usually sandy, dry Rio Grande, and listen to all sorts of people talking in my ear during a time when we weren’t coming into direct contact with our friends and colleagues.

                  After County Attorney Christina Sanchez took over in June 2024 and DA James Montoya took office in January 2025, the need became even more apparent to help our community heal from the traumas of the pandemic, the de- lays in the criminal and civil justice system, and the ramifications of a previous DA’s actions. At around this time, Mr. Montoya hired a new Special Projects Administrator whom I had gotten to know in the previous few years thanks to, yep, you guessed it, a podcast. Stephanie Valle, a 20-year veteran evening news anchor at the local ABC News affiliate and an accomplished, award-winning podcaster, came to work at the DA’s Office in January 2025. When I pitched the idea of a podcast, it was an easy sell for her. Having hosted the Borderland Crimes Podcast,[4] one I listened to on my long runs, Stephanie right away saw the value of using that format to shine a light on the life-saving and empowering work both of our offices do. We landed on Justice Matters as the title.

                  Although it is true that the idea was an easy sell for Stephanie, she was daunted by the potential workload especially after having taken on a new position. Her Borderland Crimes Podcast was highly produced and required a great deal of time and effort to create (research, scripting, editing, etc.). With this in mind, we came up with ways to keep it simple.

Keeping it simple

In the first place, Justice Matters does not tackle the true crime format. We do not go in-depth on pending cases, and to the extent we discuss cases at all, they are not the focus. Instead, the format includes topical interviews of prosecutors and staff from both offices. At the beginning of each nine-episode season, the DA and CA do a joint interview, giving them a chance to catch listeners up on their challenges, successes, and considerations in the future.

                  Then we move to episodes on topics that overlap both offices, such as domestic violence, safe communities, border crime, and safeguarding children. In one episode, “Victims Matter,” we interviewed Elizabeth Rios, the Director of Victims Services at the DA’s Office, and John Dominguez and Claudia Pinales, both Victim Assistant Coordinators in the CA’s Office. In another (“Prosecution of Murder Matters”), we interviewed prosecutors who handle murders in both offices. We spotlighted staff in non-lawyer roles, who are key parts of both offices in “Administrative Matters” and “Tech Matters.” We even talked Rebecca Tarango and Eddie Sosa, the first assistants in both offices, into being guests because we all know “First Assistants Matter.” You get the idea.

                  Consider a few of the logistics. We keep the recording to around 30 minutes (for me the death knell for a podcast is one that goes on too long!). In the interests of keeping the preparations easy, we ask the same four questions in every episode.

                  1) “Who are you?” We ask this to get a glimpse of the interviewee as an actual person rather than just the position. We get varying degrees of personal information or sharing, often pets’ names and hobbies. 

                  2) “What do you do?” This broad question gets all sorts of responses and is most often the sweet spot for the guests in terms of comfort in answering.

                  3) “Why does your work matter?” As you might imagine, this question gleans some of the most poignant responses, giving us a true picture of what the work of prosecution means to the guests.

                  4) “What do you hope to accomplish in your position?” This question helps us understand the short- and long-term thinking of both the guests and the office.

                  We record at either the DA’s or the CA’s office. We do not have an expensive recording booth or fancy headphones you see on all the other podcasts. Instead, we look for relatively quiet spaces, use good-quality microphones, and employ an in-house editor, Desmond Galvan.[5] Desmond uses free software to edit the recordings, which can include filters that help drown out errant noises and generally up the quality of the podcast. In terms of cost, everyone works on this project while on the clock and using existing equipment so there are no extra expenses.[6] It’s fair to say we have all experienced a learning curve in terms of quality of recording and content.    

Our listeners

Fun side story: We use a podcasting service that helps us monitor listenership and other key metrics. Sometime in Season Two, I noticed we had a strong fan base in Australia. “Hmm,” I thought. “Well, I guess Australians might find the U.S. Borderland interesting.” But the Aussie numbers kept rising. After a few months, I came to realize that in fact there’s another podcast called Justice Matters based in Sydney, which is more of the “true crimes” variety. I’m thinking people searched “Justice Matters” looking for that podcast and got ours as a pleasant surprise. I’m hoping. I pitched a collab—that’s the way us podcasters talk—and so we’ll see how that develops.[7]

                  Specifically regarding listenership, it has been interesting to track the numbers and get a sense of the wide reach of the medium. Spoiler alert: Justice Matters hasn’t gone viral, so don’t worry, I’m not about to leave my day job for the bright lights of podcasting. After two seasons, the all-time downloads just reached 1,600 listeners. As of today, some of the most popular episodes include:

                  •               “Transitions Matter,” the first full episode with James Montoya and Christina Sanchez, with 196 downloads.

                  •               “The Family Justice and Wellness Conference Matters”[8] with 146. This was a panel discussion from our annual domestic violence conference with the DA, CA, Sheriff Oscar Ugarte; and Assistant Police Chief Humberto Talamontes.

                  •               “Safe Communities Matter” with 92. In this episode, ADA Amanda Enriquez discussed strategies to address impaired driving, and ACA Shantal Ortega outlined nuisance and abatement strategies.  

                  According to Stephanie, who knows stuff, it takes a year or more for a podcast to catch on. So, with the support of James Montoya and Christina Sanhcez, the project continues.

                  And as the Aussie story above highlights, the reach of the podcast extends beyond the borderlands. Listeners hail from all over the country and the world.

Season Three and beyond

Season Three dropped October 1, 2026. Stephanie Valle has moved on from her position at the DA’s Office and as a result off the podcast. Frankly, I think most listeners tune in to hear Stephanie’s professional style and amazing talent in interviews, so I was a little daunted at this becoming too much of The Aaron Show. So I enlisted a variety of colleagues from both the DA’s and CA’s Offices for roving co-hosts each week.

                  And this season, for guests, we have branched out to include other people and agencies who come into contact with our offices. For instance, in “Domestic Violence Matters,” we interviewed Sandra Garcia, Executive Director of the Center Against Sexual and Family Violence; for “Human Trafficking Matters,” we interviewed Nicole Schiff, Executive Director at the Center for Hope; for “County Government Matters,” we talked with County Judge Ricardo Samaniego and County Administrator Betsy Keller. And as the season finale, “Statewide Partners Matter” included TDCAA’s very own Shannon Edmonds and the CEO of the Texas Council on Family Violence, Gloria Terry. (That episode may not have dropped [again that’s how us podcasters talk] prior to this article’s publication.)

                  In line with the current (strange?) trend, we have started airing a video version of the podcast on YouTube.[9] I say strange because I always thought the whole point of a podcast is to hear stories. But Stephanie tells me this is the latest thing in podcasting, and like I said, she knows stuff.

                  In Seasons Four and beyond, we will continue to highlight the significant work of staff and attorneys while also including more voices from the community like law enforcement, city government, and others important to Justice Matters. (See what I did there?)

Upscaling Justice Matters

Interested in getting a podcast started? You can do it. It’s cheap. It’s easy. And you can steal this format or create your own. It just takes a little creativity. Desmond and I are happy to help you get started, help with logistics, and offer any other thoughts or advice you need. Heck, I’ll even be your first co-host.


[1]  “Strange Days Indeed,” Texas District and County Attorney Association, The Texas Prosecutor, July-August 2025, www.tdcaa.com/journal /strange-days-indeed.

[2]  “Healing the Rupture,” Texas District and County Attorney Association, The Texas Prosecutor, September-October 2026, www.tdcaa.com/journal/ healing-the-rupture.

[3]  Consider taking a listen to the Healing Arts from the Borderland, which is a project of the Borderland Rainbow Center. In its own way this podcast seeks to heal The Rupture by championing the ways that artists—defined very broadly—can use their art to heal from trauma. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/healing-arts-from-the-borderland/id1532959377. While you’re at it, take a listen to the third podcast I host related to preventing teen dating violence. In the Jennifer’s Angels Podcast, a project of Jennifer Ann’s Group (https://jenniferann.org), teen hosts join me in interviewing folks such as principals, our police chief, and others to explore challenges and approaches to fostering a healthy self-image in young people. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/jennifers-angels/id1894252102.       

[4]  Add the Borderland Crimes Podcast to your queue: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/borderland-crimes/id1470004394. If you’re one of those true crime fans, this one is for you.

[5]  Desmond deserves special recognition for all the work he puts into this podcast as well as the two others I mentioned above. He not only has to deal with all of the editing including the “ums” and “uhs” and “you knows,” but he also has to listen to my voice a great deal. By the way, he was the guest in the “Tech Matters” episode.

[6]   If your office doesn’t have in-house tech folks able or willing to take on editing, there might be a cost. Because I work with Desmond on the other podcasts and he does those in his extra time, I know his going rate is $150 an episode, for a total of $1,350 for a nine-episode season. Of course, you may have a different market in your community which could contribute to a higher or lower rate.

[7]  Ours is called Justice Matters Podcast and the Aussie one is Justice Matters: Conversations About Crime & Punishment: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast /justice-matters-conversations-about-crime-punishment/id1719545435). Turns out there’s another called Justice Matters with Glenn Kirscher, https:// podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/justice-matters-with-glenn-kirschner/id1666662304.

[8]  Look for more on this conference in an upcoming issue of The Prosecutor journal. In a nutshell, our annual Family Justice and Wellness Conference (FJWC) combines key information and instruction on effective response to domestic violence, stalking, and sexual assault with a recognition of the need for wellness of those serving survivors. Think sessions on sexual assault prosecution, protective orders for minors, and prevention strategies, with wellness sessions sprinkled in, including mini cello and other concerts, sound baths, and making sugar scrubs. Learn more details on the FJWC at www.facebook.com/share/p/1HeaJAW53F and/or feel free to email me (a.setliff@epcountytx.gov) for more information. Between Seasons Three and Four, we plan to include a special series from the sessions at the FJWC as episodes on Justice Matters.

[9]  www.youtube.com/@TheJusticeMattersPodcast.